Channel 5 released its Albania documentary on 2 November, four weeks after promising the Rama interview “next week”. The film says one thing about Sazan and its host says another in the room. Rama answers with the SPAK chief’s words and with a figure that was never SPAK’s. What the film claims, what was said, and what the public record says about both.
the Tirana Examiner Newsroom
On 7 October the American YouTube outlet Channel 5 posted a short clip of Edi Rama getting up from an interview with its host, Andrew Callaghan. The caption read that the prime minister “walks out of interview with Channel 5’s Andrew Callaghan amidst wider investigations of corruption, money laundering, drug trafficking & the PM’s business relationship with Jared Kushner. Full interview will drop next week.” It dropped on 2 November, as the last half-hour of a 75-minute film on the Zvërnec and Sazan projects, the Tirana construction boom and the Flamingo protests. Channel 5 is distributed first on Patreon and has 3.6 million YouTube subscribers. The film is overdubbed in English with an Albanian audio track; the interview was conducted in English.
By Callaghan’s own account he did not obtain the interview. He had filmed the Green Coast, Sazan and Zvërnec, eaten at the Gjurma restaurant in Vlora and decided to “pack my bags and just go chill somewhere” when, he says, “I got a phone call from Prime Minister Edi Rama.” Rama greeted him as Channel 4, was corrected, and asked: “So tell me what you want from me.”
What the film claims
Everything before the interview is Channel 5’s case, built from Callaghan’s narration, protesters, activists, a former police general director who declined to name anyone, and unnamed commentators. Its spine is that Kushner’s Affinity Partners “illegally purchased land from an alleged Miami-based drug lord named Artur Shehu using falsified documents”, resting on “an Ottoman language document from 1901” recording an ancestor’s grazing land; that Kushner, “with the aid of Shehu, received fast-track approval from current Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama to develop a $4.4 billion luxury resort”, most of it funded by two Qatari-based investors the film names as Ramiz and Mutaz al-Khayyat; that Kushner “did just make a $125 million payment” to Shehu, since “temporarily frozen”; and that SPAK “froze 120 million euros on June 9th of this year pending investigation”. The narration says the “December 30th of 2024” decision by Rama’s administration was “an executive order allowing for a special land designation change which enabled the private sale and development of both proposed sites”.
Around that it places the construction sector. “Between 2015 and 2024, 56.2% of all real estate funding in the country came from unexplained and illicit sources.” “More than 100 commercial skyscrapers and residential towers are currently being built in the capital city of Tirana.” The average rent of a new apartment is put at 900 euros against an average income “still less than 400 euros”. “According to census data recently collected by the Albanian government, over 356,000, or 32% of all dwellings and apartments in the country, are currently empty.” One speaker says 85,000 apartments have been built and left unsold since 2013. The film also places a “classified meeting” on Aruba in January 2019 between Shehu, other traffickers, Albanian real-estate figures and people it presents as associates of Rama, one of them a senior official whose name it says SPAK is withholding. It says the meeting was “first leaked by Italian journalist Sigfrido Ranucci in the April of 2020”, that “a year later” a car bomb misfired outside his home in Rome, and that Italian authorities then recovered “a letter of intent directly implicating” Shehu in ordering the attack. It puts Albanian groups in control of “Ecuador’s four main commercial ports” and their revenue at “over $18 billion last year, which is over half of Albania’s GDP”.
On Sazan the film says what its interviewer will later contest. “Sazan Island, the one that Jared fell in love with, is not the one that he paid for.” “No payments were ever sent for Sazan Island. It’s in no stage of development.” The narration calls the 1.6-billion plan “the decoy Sazan project”. Callaghan climbs the island halfway, finds broken glass, brambles and no vipers, and concludes that Ivanka Trump did not walk it barefoot. The Ivanka clip the film uses says: “We were on a friend’s boat and we stopped for a swim. Factually, that’s how we found it. We swam to the islands. We went on a hike barefoot all the way up to the top.” The film’s gloss is that “back in the summer of 2021, her, Jared, Prime Minister Edi Rama, someone named Nathaniel Rothschild, and some other friends were on a yacht”.
In the room
Asked about the protests, the Flamingo Revolution and people calling for change, Rama asked back: “Do you feel like you are witnessing a revolution here?” Callaghan said he was going by what they called it. “So, it’s a protest, and it’s all okay. They have the right to protest. We are a free democratic country.” Had any concern made him want to change things? “That first, let’s say, week, when everyone was in the street, was very helpful to understand, to hear beyond the noise. And of course we have taken our own notes from that, and certain things that came up in those notes are being implemented.” His example: “the digital mirror. You had your president a few days ago exposing an AI source of information about the government. So we had launched it right away after this note of the protest in the beginning, and are now building up and implementing. For example, now you have fully online the whole transparent exposure of everything that is related to the project that has been the trigger of that outrage.” The film cuts in a news clip on Trump’s executive order launching the AI site america.gov.
Callaghan raised organised crime: groups that had grown “to pretty much conquer the cocaine market in Europe and Australia”. “Who says this?” DEA reports, SPAK intelligence and others, Callaghan said, on cocaine markets in London, in Israel and in Ecuadorian ports “under control under groups that identify as being connected to the Albanian mafia”. Rama: “I have heard the contrary from at least the director of SPAK a few years ago, that there is no such a thing like the Albanian mafia. It doesn’t exist. There are Albanians, as there are Americans, as there are Spaniards or Italians or you name it, that are involved in these kind of networks worldwide, but there’s nothing like an Albanian mafia controlling the world of cocaine. This is, sorry, BS.” Where did the BS come from? “No, but it’s BS because it doesn’t match the reality of things.” So he did not think it was happening? “This is not a matter of an opinion. I’m telling you that the director of SPAK himself, he said that the notion of an Albanian mafia does not exist.”
Callaghan then cited “the data that came out recently through SPAK”: that between 2015 and 2024 “more than 54% of money that flows through the real estate and construction sector in Albania comes from unknown and illicit sources”, adding that Rama had “had a hand in approving a lot of these developments”. “Who has said this?” “SPAK, various journalists internationally.” “SPAK never said this. No, SPAK never issued this report, because SPAK may have said something different, that from the seized money they have made some estimate that part of the seized money has been poured into real estate, but SPAK has never said this.”
On housing, Callaghan said rents were rising, wages were the same, and “there’s upwards of 55,000 empty apartment units across the city”. “What was this, 55 what?” “There’s 55,000 empty apartment units in Tirana.” “BS. Where did the number come from?” Callaghan had read it in many places. “You can read it in all the places, but it doesn’t mean that this is true. This is the world we live in today. There is not such a thing like 50,000 apartments empty in Albania. It’s nonsense.” When Callaghan began “So you think that most of these luxury…”, Rama cut across: “I don’t think. I talk here not as an opinionist, not as a journalist, not as someone that you met in the street. I talk here as the Prime Minister of the country, so I have the responsibility to talk based on data or on facts and not based on allegations. You have read, I’ve read so many things, and there are so many lies around and half-truths that are bigger than the lies, so it doesn’t mean that you say something you have read. That’s why I asked who is the source.” On the cranes and towers Callaghan said he saw everywhere: “This is another optic illusion. If you count the towers in Tirana, you’ll not arrive at ten yet. And if you count the sites where new buildings are popping up, you’ll not arrive at ten yet, because I count them.” Callaghan pressed on towers planned. “There is not such a thing like massive towers planned everywhere. This is not true. So, will we speak about facts, or will we just have a conversation that you throw here all type of things that you think you have seen or you think are true because you have read? You choose.”
Would development not be a good thing? “I didn’t say there is no development. There’s a lot of development. You said that the cost is rising, the wages are the same. This is another inaccurate assessment, because the GDP of this country has been less than 10 billion euro when I started, and this year is predicted to just touch the, unimaginable until some years ago, level of 30 billion euros. So it’s three-fold higher. And the wages today are not, of course, in the level of the EU, but are much higher than they were. And the last increase of wages has been last year.” So the protesters were incorrect? “I don’t feel like all these protesters are incorrect. I feel like there are a lot of reasons to be critical about things. I am very self-critical about things, but about facts. Not about imaginations.” Asked for the best economic driver of his premiership: “We had less than 2 million tourists when I started to serve as Prime Minister, and we are well above 12 million. So just from tourism, what comes to the country is above 8 billion.” Callaghan called that great news. “There are many great news about Albania, but you are not here for great news. You are here for the bad news. So I’m trying to balance.”
Callaghan asked for the current status of the Sazan project. “You tell me.” He had been there, nothing was going on, and he had seen that the money was frozen. “This is another BS. There are no money, in any shape or form, related to these projects, because it’s not a project.” The film cuts in: “Despite Edi Rama saying that the project funds weren’t frozen, his own special prosecution office, SPAK, froze 120 million euros on June 9th of this year pending investigation.” Rama: “Well, listen. Sazan is a public land. If you don’t know, I’m informing you. And as we speak, there is not yet a deal between the Republic of Albania and the group that want to invest in Sazan. We are negotiating. There is not yet a deal. Not money, not project, there is not yet a deal. While you guys have fooled the world, not you personally, not your channel, sorry. Fooled the world telling that the island is privatised, the flamingos in the island, which have never crossed the island, are going to be killed and eaten for breakfast from Trump, and all these things. There’s not yet a deal. We’re negotiating a deal because we are going to, hopefully, create the joint venture where the Republic of Albania will be partner. And this is what I’m saying, and many more you can find in the Flamingo Mirror .al, which shows that 90% of what is said is a lie.” Asked for the biggest lie he wanted cleared up for an American audience, Rama listed three: “That an island is privatised. SPAK is investigating the investment. 10,000 apartments will be built in a very pristine virgin nature. And more and more and more.”
Then the yacht. “What can you tell us about that yacht trip that you took with Ivanka and Jared?” “I never took a yacht trip with Ivanka and Jared. This is another lie.” The film plays Ivanka Trump: “We spent a couple days in Albania. One of the nights their Prime Minister Rama came to the boat. I had not met him when I was in government.” Callaghan said she had said they were on a yacht and she jumped off. “No, she never said that. She said that she jumped off, but she didn’t say I was in the yacht, because I never took a trip. I went to welcome them when they stopped at the Durrës port for refuelling, and they were part of this crew of a yacht that was a yacht of someone I know, the son of Jacob Rothschild, who was the caretaker and donor for many years of a very, very important archaeological site.” “I met at the yacht while the yacht was refuelling, staying in the dock, and we had dinner and I left.” Did he think she had really jumped? “Holy mother of Mary. I don’t know what she did when they were having the trip. You said to me, I had a trip in the yacht. I never had a trip.” Callaghan said that was what had been reported. “It was reported because, as many are the things that are reported, [it was a] lie.” “Well, thanks for clearing that up.” “No, I don’t think I cleared anything up, because this will not hold. What will hold is that I was in the yacht having a trip.”
Would he have warned her about the vipers? “I am not aware of vipers in the island. I learned that they exist from New York Times.” Callaghan said he had been on the island. “Didn’t a snake bite you? No vipers?” None, Callaghan said, though he had kept his shoes on. “They were not there to welcome you, but you are lucky that they didn’t bite you. So I don’t know. New York Times spoke about vipers.” Where had he and Ivanka gone out? “Are you following me or not? We were at the yacht. The yacht was parked at the port for the night. We got inside, and they were ten people having dinner inside, and I was invited, and I welcomed them, and I left to go to my home. What’s so difficult for you?” Callaghan said he believed him. “You believe me, but you are not following me.” Callaghan said Rama had said “refuelling station”. “I never used the word refuelling station. You used it. We are on the record. I met them at the yacht while the yacht was refuelling. I said that they were stopped for refuelling. I didn’t say in a refuelling station, because I never seen refuelling stations of boats. I know that the boats refuel in a port, not in a station like the cars. But maybe in your part of the world boats come in the road and refuel in the station. I don’t know.”
Did he know who owned the restaurant they went to that night in Vlora? The narration says photographs placed the two at Gjurma, “owned by Artur Shehu, the same Albanian drug trafficker implicated in the deed forgery and the fraudulent land deal with Jared Kushner”. Rama: “In the yacht we got the dinner. What restaurant?” Callaghan said there was a picture of him at Gjurma. “This is much later. It’s not the same. This is this year, in the beginning of this year. My God. And the restaurant I was with her is not Gjurma. The restaurant I was with her is another restaurant that is opened this year.”
What did he know about Artur Shehu? “What should I know? I know that he is under investigation. And that’s it.” Had he spoken to him? “I don’t know him. I never met him. I don’t know even how he looks like.” But Shehu sold the land to Affinity Partners. “Why I care?” Because it was his country. “No, but what does it mean, who sold the land? He is part of the owners with titles of property that are in the register of the state. And this is how it works in the United States. This is how it works in Europe. This is how it works in Brazil, in Peru. Only in China works differently.” Callaghan raised the chaos of deed forgery after 1991. “Again, every land has an owner or not. The owner is the one that has a title of property. The title of property derives from the registry. Among the guys that had the title properties in that part of private land, it’s the guy you mentioned. So they had a transaction. Where is the thing here?” Callaghan said the land was ecologically protected, with an active monastery on it. Rama: “That land has always been under the status of protected landscape.” Callaghan: but Shehu’s documents rested on the 1901 Ottoman paper. “Sir, listen. I’m not his lawyer. I’m not his prosecutor. I’m not his judge. I’m the Prime Minister of Albania. And what I can tell you is that for as long as a title is in the register of properties of the country, this title is legit. If the investigation will show else, and if the court will decide so, then the title will be put in discussion. And the company, the investments, the investors have nothing to do with this individual beyond the fact that he was one of the owners. They made the deal with the owners. They paid the money, and they are now the owners. This is it. The owners today of that land are the investors.”
Callaghan said Rama’s administration had given fast-track approval turning a protected area into land that could be sold to private developers. “Lie.” The narration cuts in with the 30 December 2024 decision. “We didn’t give any fast-track approval to this investment. And by the way, we don’t have yet an approval, my friends. You know it, or you are not aware of it?” Callaghan said he knew the money was frozen, “the 220 million”. “You go back to the money now. I’m talking about the approval. But again, the transaction has been accepted as legit by SPAK, okay? So they have paid the money and they are the owners. The money will stay in an escrow account until the process will end. If Artur Shehu is the legitimate owner, he’ll take the money. If he’s not, the state will take the money.” “The land was a restitution of property made many years ago, long before I came to government. It was not purchased. The land was never purchased. The land was restituted.” To Shehu? “To his family.” On the 1901 document? “Based upon whatever it was considered to be based.” Callaghan said there were convictions, not just allegations, that the family had used that stretch of coast for smuggling people to Italy in the 1990s. “This is something I don’t know, and it’s not related to what we’re talking. In communism we used to judge people based on families. Here in democracy we judge facts. And we judge individuals. We don’t judge families.”
So was corruption a matter of individual responsibility, whether it was the mayor of Tirana or anyone else? “I feel that is not for you to say who is corrupt or who is not corrupt.” Callaghan said he was not saying who was corrupt. “Yeah, you are saying.” He cited the head of the intelligence service, “less than two weeks ago arrested for having an affair with an organised crime figure here”. “I don’t know why you mix things. What has this to do now with the investment in the coast?” Callaghan said he meant people convicted of corruption. “[Which] people convicted of corruption?” “We could go to Pëllumb Gjoka.” “What are these stories?” The narration describes Gjoka as “Edi Rama’s strategic investor for years”, sentenced to six years for providing the conditions and means for a murder, participation in organised crime and bribery of justice officials, over a contract killing ordered with a former police chief against three people in the way of his hotel. Rama: “What are you trying to do here? I don’t understand. I’m not here to feed your curiosity. You can have all the curiosities. Can you ask questions about the facts and the project, or are you here to go from one to one to one?” Callaghan said Rama had asked him for an example. “You mentioned the mayor of Tirana. You mentioned the head of intelligence. These people are innocent until proven guilty. Just for you to know, because they are not convicted. So what is the story here you want to make?” On Gjoka: “And so what? He has been convicted, and so what?” Callaghan said Gjoka had been a strategic investor for the government. “[You have no] idea what it is to be a strategic investor, my friend. So you don’t mention it like something that is a privilege. It’s a status during a process, and yes, he has had this status, which was immediately lifted when upon him was pending a conviction. This is how it works.” “Everything that has to do with individuals is individual responsibility.”
Callaghan asked how he felt about people around him being convicted. “No, but how you know how I feel? What do you know about my feeling? But what does it mean, you feel? What is this? I’m not here to share the feelings with you, young man. I’m here to answer questions about facts.” Callaghan said he was also the prime minister. “Sure, otherwise we would never [have met]. But what is your point? What do you want to say? What do you want to tell your audience? You came from America to do what? To gossip with me here?” To give him a chance to clear things up, Callaghan said. “No, I don’t need your chances. I’m here just to welcome you respectfully, giving you my precious time, and you have to use my time with respect.”
What did 7 October mean to him? “It’s a horrific thing that happened.” Did he have opinions on the plight of the Palestinians? “Of course. Albania has since long time a very clear stance. We have always stood for the two-state solution. But until Hamas is around, there is no chance for any other solution than to wipe out Hamas. This is my opinion. Until Hamas is fully dismantled, its two million prisoners will never be truly free.”
Callaghan said he would like to see more faith in government from young people, especially Gen Z. “Who are you to talk on behalf of the Albanian young people? I don’t understand. You talked to a bunch of them, but there are many Albanian young people out there. There are them who have some opinions, there are the others who have some other opinions. So as everywhere in the world.” What could restore public faith? “First of all, to find a way to stop the floods of the public space with so many lies by the second, coming from all over and being perpetuated all over. And this is not just the media. This is the responsibility of the social media. And then the media, of course, is being more and more obliged to follow, because speed is needed, because virality is needed, because likes and followers are needed, and so all of us, we are screwed up. This is how it happens. If we don’t have a baseline, we don’t find anymore how to communicate. Until not long ago, at least in our lifetime, we had a baseline. We started from facts. Facts were not disputed as being opinions. Now, unfortunately, facts have become opinions, and the end is coming.” The end of the world? “Not of the world. Of the democracy as we are used to think of it and as we want it to be. It’s coming. Fascism is at the gates, and all this confusion is going to bring us to the dark times that we all thought were over.”
Who was the spearhead of fascism today? “Hamas.” Not Trump, Callaghan asked, “the rise of an AI technocrat establishment controlling the defense contracting world, all of our data being uploaded, total surveillance state”? “What are you talking about? Listen, there is a saying in English: be careful for what you wish. Now you enter in an area that is yours, is not mine. You are the American guy, you are the American journalist, you are the American citizen, so I would not dare to tell you how America is working or functioning. This is your opinion, I respect. So, unlike you, I don’t speak on behalf of the American young people.” Would Hamas’s ideology spread worldwide? “No, I don’t think it spreads. You said which is the most fascist thing you have seen. And the most fascist thing I’ve seen, which is Nazi, by the way, is Hamas.” Would Hamas end global democracy? “No, no, I didn’t say that. The democracy is ending not because fascism is at the gates, but fascism is at the gates because democracy is ending under our watch and we are doing nothing.” An example? “We have lost the baseline, my friends. Fascism is a devil that grows exactly where confusion dominates, and where people are in barricades and people don’t listen anymore to each other, and people blame the Jews, blame the Muslims, blame the immigrants, blame this, blame that, because they think that they are right, everyone is wrong, and they listen only to the echo chamber of their own opinion, which is multiplied. Until some years ago a Nazi in America would be hiding in a little room with his little funny and shameful cross, having two friends or three friends. Today Nazis have their own space in the social media, and they are a lot.” So global white supremacy was rising? “No, I don’t think that. I don’t know what we’re talking about. I’m saying something else.”
He ended it there. “Well, sir, I think the discussion was very interesting. I hope your viewers were entertained. Now the area you entered is all yours. You should find other Americans to discuss these things. I’m sure you have them who think like you and you have them who think against you. And again, it will be a big confusion between you and them, because the baseline is over, and this is how all of us, without realising, help the coming of fascism closer to us.” Callaghan: “But it’s not Hamas and it’s not Nazis.” Rama: “Okay. Thank you so much. I’ll see you later.” Callaghan: “All right, mate.” The last question about Kushner, Sazan or Zvërnec had come eleven minutes earlier, in the exchange over escrow.
Dumani’s answer
The statement Rama attributed to the SPAK chief exists. Altin Dumani gave it to La Repubblica on 10 April 2023. Asked whether one could speak of an “Albanian mafia”, he said the term was one used by the media and academic circles and not a legal term in Albanian criminal law; that Albania today had no criminal structures resembling Cosa Nostra, the ‘Ndrangheta, the Camorra or the Sacra Corona Unita; that Albanian groups were built on close family and social ties without a clear hierarchy, operated in small groups, and had no single leader. That is the half Rama quoted. In the same interview Dumani said these groups had managed to influence the cocaine and cannabis markets of EU countries, listing Greece, Italy, Spain, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Germany, Denmark and Britain, and that the past decade had seen a rise in wholesale cocaine shipments from South America controlled by Albanian groups, built on ties with cartels in Ecuador, Colombia, Peru, Brazil and Mexico. That is the half Callaghan was asking about.
Whose 56.2 per cent
The film’s narration puts the share of real-estate funding from “unexplained and illicit sources” between 2015 and 2024 at 56.2 per cent. In the room Callaghan rounded it to “more than 54%”, called the sources “unknown and illicit” and attributed it to SPAK. The number comes from a study published by the Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung in Tirana in September 2025, by Prof. Adriatik Kotorri. It records building permits for 11.48 million square metres over the decade, with a market value of 16.238 billion euros, of which 7.108 billion is identified as financed from bank loans (5.521 billion) and foreign direct investment (1.587 billion). The remaining 9.13 billion, 56.2 per cent, is the unexplained gap. The study itself says part of it may be unsold land or legitimate savings, and reserves its concern for the illicit share it cannot size. SPAK did not publish it. Rama’s denial holds on attribution. “Illicit” is not the study’s word for the whole gap either.
The film’s own numbers
The sum attached to the Zvërnec transaction appears three ways: a “$125 million payment” in the narration, “120 million euros” frozen on 9 June in the narration and from one speaker, and “the 220 million” from Callaghan in the room. The narration’s chronology of Sigfrido Ranucci has the car bomb “a year later” than an April 2020 broadcast; the attack on Ranucci’s car took place in October 2025, outside his home in Pomezia. The narration says the Gjurma photographs emerged “on the same night” as the boat stop; Rama dates the restaurant photograph to the beginning of this year and the boat stop to the earlier trip the film itself places in 2021. The film says no payment was ever made for Sazan and that the island is in no stage of development; eleven minutes later its host tells Rama the Sazan money has been frozen. On one point the two men said the same thing: the Zvërnec land “has always been under the status of protected landscape”. Callaghan put it as an accusation. Rama said it as a fact that does not touch a registered title.
Rama left the room with half of Dumani’s answer. Callaghan left it with the wrong author for his number. On Sazan the film and the prime minister agree, and the interview never noticed. The tape has all of it.