Skip to content

Why Does Emotion Drown Logic?!

15.11.26

Pundits who know the Socialist Assembly’s outcome before it opens, a detained mayor trading claims with his own party, a protest that turns aggressive when asked for reasons, a Parliament that rages until the salary vote: in Albania everyone knows the force of logic, and nobody wants to pay its social cost.

By Ben Andoni (Tirana)

 

The Socialist Party (SP) Assembly has not even begun, and nobody knows what will happen there or what chairman Edi Rama will announce beyond the few elements officially declared, yet in the media many figures know in detail what is going to happen. Even the changes in government and the messages Rama will deliver! Their certainty is astonishing, and the emotion with which they convey it makes you feel small that Albania holds so many well-informed people! Other colleagues had Rama arrested, a few months ago, the moment he set foot in the United States! From the majority, former friends of Erion Veliaj now at the top of the SP say publicly that the mayor should not hide behind the symbols, the “fist” or the “rose” of the Socialist Party. That was the assessment of Taulant Balla, head of the SP parliamentary group, who once never tired of the grandest words for him. Blendi Klosi, the SP’s Secretary General, pinned the emotion down in logical terms when he said that Veliaj’s request to take part in the National Assembly of 14 November is simply a matter for the justice bodies and not for the party structures. Without weighing the emotion of all these cases against logic, for most people one thing is emotionally clear: chairman Rama wants the Municipality of Tirana at any cost for the 2027 elections. The municipality, with its mass of employees, the interests tied to it and its budgets, is of great use. And not only for the capital. Others add, with the same emotional conviction, that whoever wins Tirana will in future be prime minister. Up to a point the facts agree, with the example of Mr Rama himself. Other groups are convinced that what is happening between Rama and Veliaj is one big show, meant to demonstrate that democracy in the Socialist Party is accomplished and can even accommodate requests such as that of Veliaj, who asks from pretrial detention to attend the SP Assembly. Here logic, with its coldness, makes you brake a little. Except that in this latest case, among the primates of the SP, the language shakes you, because there is no logic left in it, only a great deal of emotion. Just think: family is mentioned, a threat, and so on. What happened a few days ago feeds this logically, since we have only the fact of Minister Gogu’s visit, while what Veliaj writes is missing the other part of the plot, what was said to him, since the Minister of Justice rejects that claim! But why was the visit made at that late hour, logic asks coldly?! It seems the sitting mayor of Tirana has only his word, and no longer the power or the help of logic’s coldness.

Not far from this debate, in the space of political geography, the opposition claims that it raised the latest protest, the one that became international news! In fact the “Flamingos” have been alive for months, and the Democratic Party (DP) was almost non-existent among them because it was, in truth, unwanted. As much as the Socialists were. The latter now tell you they have found a common language, while the protesters, by and large, deny it. Further still: had it not been for the DP there would not be this intensity, claim the people of the opposition, through the mouth of Mr Sali Berisha and his collaborators. The protesters themselves ask for big things, and emotion is leading them in a cause that cannot materialise. Rama, on international panels, alleges the influence of Iran and foreign powers, but does not reason logically that many of the protesters’ demands are a consequence of his own problematic governance. The Protest itself turns aggressive when you ask it for logical consequences. Why did you wreck and loot private property?! many of them have been asked. That is enough for emotion to drown everything. Some of the melodramatic and the hand-warmers throw it in your face: this is how it was done in Paris too, and in other countries of the West. But remind them how they would judge if they were in the place of those who suffered the damage, and they have no answer. Logic disarms them because it is cynical. Emotion is for the public and for immediate gain.

Our Parliament, the feeder of this state of affairs, is only emotion and melodramatic venting to the point of delirium. The accusations they hurl at one another shake you, but the joint vote on salaries makes you understand that logic (at the right moment) drowns emotion and the melodrama. They become reasonable at once. It is the same when they travel in delegations to foreign countries, where they pose apart and grim-faced, but in their free time commiserate together in pubs and good restaurants. We will not add what the media finds when they use logic for business!

Why does emotion drown the life of our country? The answer is simple: logic is cold and merciless! We Albanians are not cold, even when logic says it openly: no, this is wrong. Emotion, on the other hand, binds you to the leading role. And the leading role ties many politicians and VIPs to clicks and visibility, which translate into profit. It was not for nothing that, at the protest, the chairmen of the small parties paid so much attention to their reels. The chairman of the Opportunity party (Mundësia) went so far as to improvise little scenes that ended in the thrill of supposedly being called on to become prime minister. In short, emotion is tied to the Ego and not to the truth, which is sour in Albania, and which the protest too is now feeling on its own back, through division, people’s indifference and the mistakes made so far, with or without cause, by a few false protagonists.

Logic, for its part, asks you not to carry an identity. So whoever is with the SP should have the courage to tell Rama: the vote I gave you for this last mandate is turning into disappointment, and you do not deserve it. And he or she who voted for Berisha should have the courage to say: no, it cannot go on like this. You cannot bring my party to power. But the SP’s militants would sooner still cite Berisha for the problems (!!!) than say that Rama is wrong. All the more so the people close to him; we saw their transformation in the end, when the Territorial Reform was voted. In the DP the situation is more frightening still, because every process is tied to Berisha. If Berisha comes back to the top I will resign, Gazment Bardhi once said, with logic, but today he heads the DP parliamentary group, under Berisha. The emotion he shows in parliament often drowns the logic people expect of him. Nobody in the SP or the DP dares to name their own mistakes, because it is easier to cheat on the facts than on the dazzling identity they have built. In short, here nobody debates the facts; everyone debates to display and defend themselves and to take the leading role!

Logic is cold and slow, where emotion is instant. So Rama and Berisha are at once labelled, for everything, as the evil of the country, with no regard for the conditions in which they take decisions, the circumstances, and why they are obliged to do such things. Likewise, being logical takes a few more minutes than making emotion’s quips, which take a few seconds and of which Rama and Berisha are undisputed masters. For all our argument, there is one thing that is not liked among us. And not for nothing. No one is lonelier than the man of logic. The truth is that everyone knows the force of logic, but nobody wants its social cost. Logic does not give you the sense of why a thing has meaning and what it is; it simply pronounces that this was done, that it is so or otherwise… Emotion says things about a dead man’s virtues that he, could he hear them in the afterlife, would never have imagined, and says them, what is more, through people who never loved him. So today Rama says that “we” are taking Albania into Europe and that the process is the work of the SP alone; and Berisha answers that he took Albania into NATO, while They (read: the Socialists) are only robbing Albania. We Albanians, and our politicians above all, know the force of Logic well, but we find it hard to accept, because it shows you as you are in front of the mirror. Emotion always brings you out honoured before crowds that delight in noise and emotion and that are, not infrequently, knowingly manipulated. Unfortunately, logic failed before emotion long ago among us, but the Irish writer Jonathan Swift, the father of Gulliver, said it some centuries ago more pleasantly, more clearly and with more cynicism: “It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of a thing he was never reasoned into.”

(Homo Albanicus)

Share